Best Personalized Gift Ideas
June 21, 2019

It’s generally fun to receive a gift, but it can actually be a real buzzkill when you’re given a gift that seems as if it were randomly pulled out a pile of assorted boxes and bags. The real joy of both giving and receiving gifts is the thought behind the items. Really nothing beats a gift that feels like it came from the heart, given to you by someone who actually did some careful thinking before buying it. And if you’re the one giving the present, there’s really nothing like choosing a personalized gift and really nailing it.

That being said, there’s a reason why people often don’t bother giving personalized gifts: it’s hard to successfully pull off! The right personalized gift idea requires you to not only know someone well, but also know what would excite them to unwrap from you in particular. But don’t stress — there’s now a way to find fantastic personalized gift ideas without thinking and looking for days on end. And even better news: you’ve already found it!

MASSE is your one-stop shop for recommendations and personalized gift ideas, brought to you by real people who have both given and received these amazing items. We base all of our recommendations on reviews written by users, and because we don’t allow any paid posts or sponsored reviews, you can be really confident that our personalized gift ideas aren’t impersonal spam but seriously thoughtful, authentic suggestions.

Look, we don’t know the person you’re buying this personalized gift for, but we do know, thanks to our many, many great users, what makes for a great personalized gift. In many cases, we’re recommending quality products that can be paired with inside jokes and special moments between you and your planned recipients. In other cases, our personalized gift ideas are items that everyone would love, but only people who really care about you would think to buy. You know your recipient best, we’re just here to make it easy for you to make them smile.

1
Coordinate Leather Keychain
$16.49
MrPuzzini
2
Little Bo Peep Mini Pillow
$120.00
Hill House Home
3
Personalized Family Mugs
$30.00
Uncommon Goods
4
Flowers Hand-Painted Notecards
$145.00
Bernard Maisner
5
Maxfield Napkin Rings
$26.00
Pottery Barn
1

Coordinate Leather Keychain

$16.49By: MrPuzzini
This gorgeous leather keychain from Etsy store MrPuzzini is a great personalized gift idea that combines convenience, usefulness, and the potential for a deeply meaningful message. The tan leather loop can be customized on both sides, with up to 36 characters each. You can add pretty much any text you’d like, and we’ve seen people opt for anniversary dates, initials, and even GPS coordinates of the place where they got married.
2

Little Bo Peep Mini Pillow

$120.00By: Hill House Home
The Little Bo Peep mini pillow from Hill House Home is equal parts soft and adorable. It’d make a great personalized gift for a number of different potential recipients, especially new (or newish) parents. There’s something about it that just makes you feel calm and put a smile on your face. It’ll look good in a crib or bed, but could also make a great accent pillow for a couch. Anyone who receives this pillow will know you love them.
3

Personalized Family Mugs

$30.00By: Uncommon Goods
It’s hard to please everyone in a family, but this personalized family mug set from Uncommon Goods is pretty much guaranteed to do the trick. You can build a fun cartoon version of each family member receiving one of these mugs, with all kinds of customizable options, from skin color and hair type to clothing and accessories. You can emblazon each family member’s name on their respective mugs, making it super clear that this personalized gift is really custom-made for them.
4

Flowers Hand-Painted Notecards

$145.00By: Bernard Maisner
Usually, a card is a bit of an afterthought, and at best a sweet addition to a gift that is the main attraction, but these bespoke, handcrafted notecards are gorgeous enough to be considered a gift themselves. Master calligrapher Bernard Maisner makes these stunning, hand-painted cards, complete with their gold engraving; no two cards are alike, so you’re not just giving someone a great personalized gift, you’re giving them a piece of art. As MASSE shoppers note, Maisner takes some requests and will even create a custom monogram, bringing personalization to the next level.
5

Maxfield Napkin Rings

$26.00By: Pottery Barn
If you have a friend or loved one who loves to host dinner parties (or just get all decked out for a normal dinner at home, no judgment here), you can help make their events extra special with these monogrammed Maxfield Napkin Rings from Pottery Barn. You can get them personalized or add any letter to the silver ring, making for a smart, subtle, but always appreciated personalized gift idea.