Best smudge-proof eyeliner
April 12, 2019

The best eyeliner needs to perform two huge jobs: First, it’s got to enhance and define your eyes, and then it has to last all day. Unfortunately, too many eyeliners can send you from stunning to smudged with just a little bit of sweat or even quick eye rub, and there are few things people notice faster than a big ol’ mess dark around your eyes. That makes finding the best smudge-proof eyeliner absolutely crucial, and MASSE has got you covered with smudge-proof eyeliners chosen by real shoppers like you.

MASSE is the only user-driven shopping platform that provides only real recommendations and answers from people who really use the products. The internet is overflowing with sites that host paid posts, fake reviews and sponsored content, but MASSE is powered by real shoppers who love sharing their favorite products. These recommendations for the best smudge-proof eyeliner come straight from our users, who know what it’s like to deal with smearing and raccoon eyes and want to help you avoid them!

There are all kinds of different eyeliner styles, from subtle pencil lines to splashy liquid-based designs. Eyeliner is a pretty solid indicator of someone’s overall aesthetic adventurousness and each kind offers its own advantages. The classic eyeliner pencil is a tried and true way to apply a fine line relatively quickly. They’re great for smoky eye but tend to smudge a bit, but MASSE users have recommended some great pencil eyeliners that don’t run or spread. They’re an easy way to apply some effective, eye-defining makeup and never go out of style. The best eyeliner pencils are smudge-proof, slip-proof, and trend-proof.

Then you’ve got liquid eyeliner, which tends to take a bit more concentration to apply but pays off in stunning, long-lasting looks. In addition to being smudge-proof, the liquid eyeliner recommended by MASSE users can work all kinds of wonders.They enhance the eyes and are perfect for exacting looks like cat eye and rounded derivatives, and they can also be used in tandem with other eyeliner types to create a more complex and alluring effect. But no matter what style you’re looking for, MASSE users can recommend the best smudge-proof eyeliner for your needs.

1
Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner in Black
$22.00
Stila
2
Eyeko Skinny Liquid Eyeliner
$22.00
Eyeko
3
NARS Eyeliner Pencil
$24.00
NARS
4
Aqua XL Eye Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner
$21.00
Make Up For Ever
5
Infallible Never Fail Pencil Eyeliner
$9.49
L’Oreal Paris
Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner is the best of both worlds — it comes in pen form, so it’s easy to apply, yet it’s a quick-drying liquid that “stays in place forever,” as MASSE users rave. If you want distinct, stunning eyes without having to worry about smearing or spending much time in front of the mirror, Stila’s Stay All Day is one of the best smudge-free eyeliners around.
Take control with Eyeko Skinny Liquid Eyeliner, a pen-liner that creates sharp, alluring eyes with the ease of a traditional pencil liner. As one MASSE shopper noted, no matter how many times they rub their eyes, the eyeliner doesn’t smear, and many other rave that it “draws on like marker,” but creates a very sophisticated look. Eyeko’s smudge-proof liquid eyeliner is easy to use and lasts all day, making it a favorite of so many shoppers.
3

NARS Eyeliner Pencil

$24.00By: NARS
NARS is one of MASSE users’ favorite eyeliner brands, and its eyeliner pencil goes on smooth and lasts for 12 hours without smearing or wearing away. Eye pencils aren’t always known for their longevity, but NARS has intense pigments that give eyes definition, accentuate lashes, and don’t smudge, even in heat. MASSE shoppers consider it a “go-to” eyeliner thanks to its versatility and great price point.
4

Aqua XL Eye Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner

$21.00By: Make Up For Ever
Want a smudge-proof eyeliner for every occasion? Make Up For Ever’s excellent Aqua XL Eye Pencil has got you covered, with a wide array of colors that go on smooth and never smear. With colors ranging from black matte to pastel yellow and “pop purple,” you’ll never get bored and you’ll definitely never get raccoon eyes. MASSE users rave that this eyeliner is “incredible” and love that it “lasts forever, too.”
5
L’Oreal Paris is one of the most trusted names in beauty, a distinction earned by high-quality and reliable products like the Infallible Never Fail Pencil Eyeliner. It’s easy to apply, with a smooth glide and a built-in sharpener that keeps it ready to go at any time. Its smudge-proof stick lasts up to 16 hours, which should be far longer than you’d ever need it (unless you’re having a very crazy night). MASSE users describe it as “awesome!!” “great!” and “amazing!!,” and you can’t argue with that number of exclamation points!