How to fill in eyebrows with pencil

November 13, 2019

Eyebrow styles have tended to run from pencil-thin to natural and thick, depending on the decade — the ‘90s, for example, were all about those supermodel-thin brows, as if they were totally waxed and put on with an eyebrow pencil, while the beginning of this current decade saw the rise of very full, bushy but sculpted eyebrows thanks to the likes of Kim Kardashian, Cara Delevigne, and other big names. Now, we’re living in a golden age of eyebrow styles, with a wide range of what’s seen as cool, from thin to thick and natural to carefully sculpted. It’s a huge relief, because no matter what kind of eyebrows you naturally have, you can find a style that works with you.

But no matter how you’re styling your brows, you should own an excellent eyebrow pencil to help ensure that you’re filling in and fixing up your look. It’s not hard to learn how to fill in eyebrows with pencil, and it’s an even bigger no-brainer to actually own one of these pencils.

People have been using eyebrow pencils to finish off and polish their looks for generations, because they’re fast, easy, and highly effective, whether you’re arching, filling in, and or finely sculpting. Unlike tweezers or scissors, eyebrow pencils have the advantage of being as temporary as you want them to be — one wrong movement with a tweezer might lead to months of awkwardness, but a stray eyebrow pencil stroke can be erased with ease. And honestly, even if you’re doing some tweezing, you should have a good eyebrow pencil at the ready anyway, just in case you need to fill in a bit more than you were expecting. It doesn’t take a great artist to know how to fill in eyebrows with pencil, either — a few strokes here and there can make a world of difference.

All that said, not all eyebrow pencils are created equal — and to be honest, the line between the good and the bad ones isn’t even all that fine. You need to find eyebrow pencils that are durable but sharpen easily, roll on with precision, and match the color you’re going for (whether that’s natural or something more contrasting is totally your call). MASSE makes it easy to find the best eyebrow pencils to fit your accessorizing needs, because we recommend brow pencils based solely on real reviews from people who have really used them. The last thing we want is people arching their eyebrows in skepticism at our recommendations, so we don’t allow any paid reviews or sponsored posts, either — we are all about honest recommendations that will help you fill in, sculpt, or feather your best brows.

  • Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define

    $24.00

    By Benefit Cosmetics

    Benefit Cosmetics’ Precisely, My Brow Pencil is a two-for-one secret weapon for filling out eyebrows and making them look positively natural. The precision tip allows you to shape your brows with long strokes or fill out your brows with shorter strokes in the direction your hair naturally grows. You can make them look even more natural and soft by using the spoolie on the other side of the pencil. MASSE shoppers say they “absolutely love” this eyebrow pencil, and use it every single day!

  • Brow Definer

    $23.00

    By Anastasia Beverly Hills

    Anastasia Beverly Hills hit the nail on the head when they named this eyebrow pencil the Brow Definer, because its versatility makes it possible to shape and fill in your brows no matter the style you’re looking for. This eyebrow pencil has three different edges to make shaping all brows eyes, and MASSE shoppers say it’s even super-helpful for people who barely have eyebrows at all. “It gives a perfect natural but noticeable look to your brows,” one shopper raved.

  • Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

    $4.79

    By Maybelline New York

    Maybelline New York’s Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil has all the tools and applicator surfaces you need to ensure that you get as fine or as thick an eyebrow as you want, filled in to your exact specifications. Plus, you’ll love the spoolie end, which will allow you to style and blend as needed, with as much detail as you desire. MASSE shoppers call this eyebrow pencil “amazing” and some even like it better than the Anastasia line!

  • The Precision Brow Pencil

    $26.00

    By Kevyn Aucoin

    Kevyn Aucoin was an iconic makeup artist who styled some of the biggest stars in the world and made the sculpted brow a sensation. His makeup line company continues his legacy, and this precision brow pencil is a perfect tool to ensure your brows look as good as they would had Kevyn done them himself. It’s a dual-purpose tool, with a spoolie and thin pencil, allowing you to sculpt and style your brows with no other tools needed. MASSE shoppers love that it’s high quality without a high price tag!

  • Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil

    $34.00

    By Hourglass

    Usually, an eyebrow pencil is only one of several options for people looking to fill out and sculpt their brows, but the Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil from Hourglass combines all the benefits of pencils, powders, and eyebrow waxes. Its triangular tip gives you full control of your look, allowing you to shape, fill out, and sculpt your brows just how you like them. MASSE shoppers uniformly love this eyebrow pencil, calling is spoolie perfect for blending and loving the fact that its work stays put.